A FIELD GUIDE TO DESIGN INQUIRY

设计研究的三种范式

三者不是彼此排斥的方法,而是知识、决策与实践之间持续往返的三种方向。

知识流动 当前范式
Research into, for, through Design 关系图 一条从上至下、由问题推进到反思的设计过程轴。Research for design 从左侧进入过程,Research into design 通过平行覆盖带研究整个过程,Research through design 从制作与部署中产生研究。

2024–2025 / DESIGN STUDIES · IJD · CHI

每种设计范式对应的论文示例

三篇正式发表且互不重复的研究,以论文中的问题、方法与证据判断设计在研究中扮演的角色。

DESIGN STUDIES 2024 PEER REVIEWED

Functional activity and connectivity during ideation in professional product design engineers

Gerard Campbell, Laura Hay, Sam Gilbert, Chris McTeague, Damien Coyle, Madeleine Grealy

DOI 10.1016/j.destud.2024.101247
01

研究问题与背景

产品设计构思会激活多个脑区,但这些区域在专业设计师构思时如何协同仍不清楚。论文研究设计构思的神经活动与功能连接。

02

研究方法、设计角色与贡献

以 30 名专业产品设计工程师为最终样本,用 fMRI 比较设计构思、静息、工作记忆和视觉空间加工,并以 PPI 分析网络连接。设计过程是被观察和解释的对象;研究识别出执行控制、显著性、默认模式与视觉网络之间的协同。

03

归类理由与研究局限

它不以研究促成某个设计方案,也不把原型制作当作研究方法,而是直接解释设计师的构思活动,因此属于 Research into Design。局限在于尚未把神经活动与创意质量关联,控制任务选择存在取舍,相关性结果也不能直接证明预测能力与普遍性。

A CONTESTED DESIGN RESEARCH CASE

一篇难以单一归类的设计研究

一个参与式桌游设计项目,同时生成研究知识、未来技术设计的前端洞察,并反过来成为研究者分析的对象。

THE DESIGN JOURNAL 2024 VOL. 27 / NO. 2 PP. 291–311 OPEN ACCESS

Imagining inclusive technological futures through participatory board game design

Adriaan Odendaal · Karla Zavala Barreda

DOI 10.1080/14606925.2024.2304409

ORIGINAL TEXT / CLASSIFICATION SIGNALS

争议性原文

PDF P.3
JOURNAL P.291
“The purpose of this project was to use participatory game design as a provocative medium for exploring questions about and ideas for more inclusive and desirable technological futures.”
PDF P.8
JOURNAL P.296
“design practitioners can generate new knowledge from a project through reflective practice... In this paper, we followingly report on our own reflective practice in conducting the ALC Board Game project.”
PDF P.17
JOURNAL P.305
“The final outcome of the ALC Board Game project was a playable prototype... However, as this paper argues, it is the methodology used to design the game itself that can be meaningfully employed.”
PDF P.20
JOURNAL P.308
“Secondly, while the game design process is perhaps not a good source for practically applicable technological innovations, it can serve as a tool for what Sanders and Stappers call ‘front end ideation’.”